← Smart Cities Smart Cities · Research

How different technologies work in cities

We researched five technologies that can carry meter data across a city: how they work, where they shine and what to watch for. LoRaWAN, NB-IoT, Sigfox, GPRS/4G and satellite IoT.

Sigfox station satellite IoT LoRaWAN gateway NB-IoT GPRS / 4G operator base station rural, scattered dense residential basement, meter room reservoir, district inlet industry, large consumer remote source, main line

One city has many needs: dense neighbourhoods, basements, rural points and critical sites. Pick a technology to see where it fits best.

One gateway, up to 3,000 meters around it

LoRaWAN

One station, thousands of meters

Meters send small data packets to a nearby gateway. Gateways are mounted on rooftops or poles and connect to the server over the internet. The signal usually reaches inside buildings and basements too.

Strength
5-7.5 km of coverage in town, up to 3,000 meters per gateway. Reaches indoor and basement meters in most cases. No per-meter line fee, very long battery life.
Watch out
Gateways need installing and maintaining. Actual coverage depends on gateway position and building materials. Commands reach the meter after it sends data. The 868 MHz band is shared.
Good fit
Dense residential areas, indoor and basement meters, industry, rural and scattered points.

Operator network, down to the basement

NB-IoT

On the operator network, behind the walls

A cellular IoT technology on mobile operators' licensed spectrum, designed for low power use and wide coverage. The meter carries a SIM and data arrives through the operator.

Strength
No extra infrastructure. Designed to reach hard spots such as basements and meter rooms. Licensed spectrum.
Watch out
A line fee per meter. Coverage varies by operator and area and should be checked in the field. Frequent transmissions and weak signal drain the battery faster.
Good fit
Indoor and basement meters, scattered points.

Long range in open terrain

Sigfox

Tiny messages, long distances

The meter sends a limited number of very small, 12-byte messages per day. They are received by stations built nationwide by a single network operator.

Strength
Very low power use, long range in open terrain. Simple hardware on the meter side.
Watch out
The traditional service model has limits such as 140 messages a day and 4 messages back to the meter. Coverage and service availability should be checked per area.
Good fit
Meters spread over wide areas where a daily index is enough.

Reservoir, district inlet, pumping station

GPRS / 4G

Live data, two-way control

Uses the same mobile data connection as phones; GPRS is 2G, while 4G is LTE-based. The meter or data logger connects directly to the server.

Strength
The widest coverage. Data can be sent every minute; commands reach a connected device with low latency.
Watch out
High power use; frequent reading usually needs an external power supply. Line costs apply.
Good fit
District inlet meters, reservoirs, pumping stations, large consumers.

Points with no terrestrial network

Satellite IoT

Where the network ends, from the sky

Low-orbit satellites collect small data packets directly from meters or gateways in the field. Some satellite systems support LoRaWAN or NB-IoT based communication with compatible devices.

Strength
No terrestrial infrastructure needed; reaches mountainous and remote points without operator coverage.
Watch out
Data may arrive late, depending on satellite passes. Little data per message; the satellite link can use significant power depending on how often it transmits. Subscription fees apply.
Good fit
Water sources, transmission lines, remote reservoirs and booster stations.

Comparison

At a glance.

LoRaWANNB-IoTSigfoxGPRS / 4GSatellite IoT
Network Your own gatewaysMobile operatorSigfox operatorMobile operatorLow-orbit satellites
Coverage 5-7.5 km in townOperator networkOperator networkOperator networkIncluding off-grid areas
Data volume LowMediumVery lowHighLow
Battery life Very longDepends on frequency and signalVery longShortDepends on use
Commands to meter On each uplinkPossibleVery limitedLow latencyOn satellite pass
Per-meter fee NoneLine feeSubscriptionLine feeSubscription

Together

One city, many technologies.

One technology is rarely enough for a whole city. Each point connects with the technology that suits it best; the data meets on one platform and the city is monitored from a single screen.

  • dense residential LoRaWAN
  • rural, scattered LoRaWAN
  • basement, meter room LoRaWANNB-IoT
  • reservoir, district inlet GPRS / 4G
  • industry, large consumer LoRaWANGPRS / 4G
  • remote source, main line Satellite IoT
One platform

Readings from every technology are converted to one standard and shown on a single screen.